IncBizNet

Resource Centers

Special Sections

Departments

Businesses for SaleFranchise Directory

Newsletters

Help Me...

The Entrepreneurial Agenda by Robb Mandelbaum

RSS

Inc.com Featured Blogs

July 21, 2008

Can Open-Source Design Work with Cars? Is the Community the Company?

Posted at 4:01 PM

I recently had an interesting conversation with Karim Lakhani, a professor at Harvard Business School, and the author of an HBS case study on Threadless, which Max Chafkin wrote about in our June issue. I continue to be fascinated by the subject of community/user innovation since it’s a topic I’m covering in my book, and one that I think is especially relevant to Generation Y entrepreneurs. “Gen Y has grown up with IM, Facebook, MySpace, and all these platforms, so it’s a natural thing for them to think about business models that involve community, “ says Lakhani. “In my generation, GenX, the geeks have been doing it for a long time. The mental switch for Gen Y is that we can leverage communities for a range of economic opportunity. You see a lot of experimentation. They’re just trying to get a community going and then they figure out the business.”

That seems to be Ben Kaufman’s approach to Kluster (see Democratizing Innovation) -- a venture that’s fun and instructive to watch for anyone interested in this topic, since there’s lots of experimenting going on. Kluster’s first project, Knewsroom, a community-created online newspaper, folded after just 38 days. “We realized that to make this work, there needed to be an editing process and as soon as you do that, it becomes too complicated. We watched it, tweaked it and made the decision that it was not for us.” So Kaufman killed Knewsroom unsentimentally at around the same time he launched NameThis.com, where you can pay $99 for the community (about 11,000 strong but growing) to christen your new product or service with a new name. $80 of the $99 goes to community members who contribute ideas. So far, the company seems to be getting some traction, as does the other element of Kaufman’s business model: selling customized and subscription-based versions of the Kluster platform to companies that will use it for internal reward-driven idea generation and problem solving.

Another new company that’s worth watching is Local Motors, an “automotive 3.0 company” that will use an open source platform to design innovative, fuel efficient cars, to be manufactured in local “micro-factories” that will also sell and service the cars. Like Threadless, it’s both a collaborative design community and a social network. Weekly design contests pay out $1500 to winners; if a car is actually built, the designer gets $10,000. In addition to “cool car” appeal, the company makes lofty promises: greener automobiles; and local economic growth through the creation of small manufacturing facilities. Take that, GM.

It seems to me that while companies like Threadless, Kluster and Local Motors do have the potential to be industry disrupters; it’s really the process of user innovation that I find more interesting than the result. It’s messy, unpredictable, and demands that you throw yourself into experimental mode, and declare yourself willing to fail. In the meantime, though, you’ve succeeded in assembling an engaged global community of members who talk to and collaborate with one another under your watchful eye, and who just may generate the spark for your next great success.

* 5 Comments

Posted by: Michael Artemiw at July 22, 2008 9:53 AM

You mentioned the book you are writing. When do you expect it will be published?

My wife and I recently started www.kountr.com. Although we had a lot of ideas, we chose to pair down the web application to its core, a simple counter, and ask the community what ideas they had.

We learned quickly how much better the community's ideas were. We strive to implement every feature we are asked for. Rather than rewarding users for their content we are rewarding them for their great ideas, building a community in the process.

This is the real promise of technology; it should fade into the background and enable those with great ideas to put them into practice. This is the belief we are building www.kountr.com upon.

Posted by: David Mullings at July 22, 2008 10:01 AM

Nice post Donna. I especially love the story about Local Motors, really interesting concept, almost like hobby cars but full-scale and green.

All good entrepreneurs know that failure is but a learning experience and we should never be afraid to fail. The key difference between Gen Y and previous generations is that so many of us are willing to become entrepreneurs and aren't afraid to fail or take risks.

I think it has to do with growing up reading about Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and books like "Rich Dad, Poor Dad" (as well as seeing our parents complain about their jobs and even get laid off after 25 years).

Posted by: Donna Fenn at July 22, 2008 10:51 AM

Michael, thanks for your comments. Book is out next spring (McGraw-Hill). I subscribed to your Twitter Feed so I can keep an eye on your company!

Posted by: John Rogers at July 23, 2008 2:23 AM

Nice Post Donna, and thank you for the shout out. Here is my latest post. http://blog.local-motors.com/2008/07/fail-early-fail-often-fail-publically.html

Posted by: Nate Stockard at July 29, 2008 5:22 PM

I think community involvement like the companies you mentioned are great ideas. You get the best of what can be produced.

I do think there is a limit on revenue generation. Look at all of the social networking sites and open source variations: once one is successful and someone starts profiting, a group cuts loose and starts another similar company...

Post Your Own Comments










Remember personal info?




Please Post your comment only once. Clicking on Post more than once may result in multiple postings. If you don't see your comment immediately, try refreshing your browser.



Try a RISK-FREE Issue of Inc. Today!

Renew | Contact Us | Current Issue

Magazine Cover

Select Services